I guess I'm the odd one out on this recipe. I didn't go "eeeww!!" but was not really impressed with the contrast of flavors and textures. I'll stick to my plain peanut butter toast or salted tomatoes - separately. It was worth trying though, thank you for giving us something new to try.
Not sure what I think of this. It's ok, not great. The combination of tomato & peanut butter did not magically transform to a new taste sensation. It wasn't bad, I could taste peanut butter and the tomato.
just okay for me.
Well I read all the reviews and was waiting to be knocked of my feet. It wasn't bad, but I just felt like the taste of peanut butter overpowered the taste of tomatoes. But I did finish the whole slice. Thanks for an easy snack recipe:)
Well, I did actually try this out of morbid curiosity ;-)! It's not bad. Now I should let you know that I'm pregnant, so my tastes might be a little skewed, but really the tomato seems more like a fruit when served with sweet stuff. I added apricot preserves to my sandwich, and really rather enjoyed it. I may be back after my pregnancy cravings wear off to renounce this post, but for now it's definitely edible, and sometimes the only thing I want if nothing else sounds good. My midwife says it's a nice healthy snack to eat when your pregnant, so there you go.
not bad, I can't complain, I had eaten about 5 of these already (not at once) and then I remembered that I forgot to review it. A strange but good combonation that I can't get anyone else to try (imagine that).
Ok, here goes, I am not a huge fan of tomatoes unless they are on a sandwich, and I don't care for pepper. But I tried it, just as listed, and yep, its great. As for Tom Sullivan, PB and Bologna is the best, been eating it for 20 yrs, except I also put lettuce on it. Thanks for the new sandwich, and use of all the tomatoes in my garden.
I really enjoyed reading all the comments on this recipe so had to give this recipe a try for breakfast. It really is good. But hey, I like peanut butter and I like tomatoes so how can I go wrong. I just never thought of trying this combination together. Thanks!
This is my favorite summertime treat. I really like it on fresh white bread, but I also add mayonaise to the bread first, and lots of salt. This is so cool that there are so many others who love this treat! My dad loves this, but my husband thinks I'm crazy. I use the biggest summer tomato that I can find (so that I only need one thick slice to fit the bread. YUMMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!!
Why is this odd?? I thought everyone ate tomatoes....(weird people). I grew up eating tomatoes with just about anything, or with nothing but the bread and mayo. It's really good for breakfast with some tea. (guess where I come from)... But for breakfast I would have it without the peanutbutter. Thanks for posting.